Home→News→Analysis→Exporting directly or through a distributor: what changes in margin and contract
Exporting directly or through a distributor: what changes in margin and contract
Selling abroad with your own team or agent, or handing the market to a local distributor: who keeps the margin, who bears the risk and what it costs to end the relationship.
Analysis
up to 1 year
When a Portuguese SME starts selling abroad, the first decision is not the price — it is who sits between the company and the end customer. There are two basic routes:
- Direct exporting: the company sells to the foreign customer itself, with its own sales team or with an agent who promotes sales on its behalf and earns a commission.
- Local distributor: the company sells to a distributor in the destination country, which buys the goods and resells them on its own account, keeping the margin.
The difference looks commercial, but it is mainly economic and contractual: it changes who keeps the margin, who bears the risk and, often forgotten, how much it costs to leave the relationship.
Direct exporting (with or without an agent)
The company keeps the final price, the customer relationship and the market information. In return, it bears fixed costs abroad (travel, trade fairs, a person dedicated to the market) and the collection risk on each customer.
If it uses an agent, in Portugal the contract is governed by Decreto-Lei n.º 178/86 (Portuguese commercial agency law), as amended by Decreto-Lei n.º 118/93. Points that weigh on the decision:
- Exclusivity in favour of the agent only exists if agreed in writing (art. 4).
- Non-compete after the contract ends: it must be in a written document, lasts two years at most and is limited to the area or customers entrusted to the agent (art. 9).
- Termination of an open-ended contract requires minimum written notice of one month in the 1st year, two months from the start of the 2nd year and three months in all other cases (art. 28). Whoever fails to respect it compensates the other party (art. 29).
- Goodwill indemnity (indemnização de clientela): if the agent brought in new customers or substantially increased business, and the company keeps benefiting from it, the agent is entitled to compensation after the contract ends (art. 33). It is set on equitable grounds, with a cap of one year’s remuneration, calculated on the average of the last five years (art. 34).
Local distributor
The distributor buys, stores, resells and collects. The company sells fewer units at the final price, but trades margin for lower fixed costs and lower risk: one customer (the distributor) instead of dozens, with no structure of its own in the country.
The less visible side is contractual. The distribution (or commercial concession) contract has no specific statute in Portugal, and the courts apply agency-contract rules to it by analogy. Supreme Court of Justice ruling n.º 6/2019, which harmonises case law, confirmed that the goodwill indemnity may also be owed to a distributor when the contract ends, with the art. 33 requirements adapted to this contract.
Other practical points:
- Direct contact with the end customer is lost and, with it, much of the market information — unless the contract requires the distributor to share it.
- Territorial exclusivity and resale restrictions are also subject to the European competition rules on vertical agreements (Regulation (EU) 2022/720). They are worth reviewing with a lawyer before signing.
Which country’s law applies
Art. 38 of DL 178/86 only protects the application of Portuguese law when the activity takes place exclusively or mainly in Portugal. In exporting, the agent or distributor works abroad, and the applicable law may be that of the destination country. Choosing the governing law and competent court in writing is one of the clauses that weighs most on the cost of ending the relationship.
An example with numbers
Calculation assumptions, not market values: product sold to the end customer at €100, variable cost of €55.
- Direct: the company keeps the €100 and bears €60,000/year of fixed costs in the market.
- Distributor: the company sells to the distributor at €75 (the distributor keeps €25) and spends €10,000/year following the market.
| Units sold per year | Result — direct | Result — distributor |
|---|---|---|
| Break-even point | 1,334 units | 500 units |
| 1,000 | -€15,000 | €10,000 |
| 2,000 | €30,000 | €30,000 |
| 3,000 | €75,000 | €50,000 |
Under these assumptions, the distributor wins while the market is small; from 2,000 units a year, direct selling earns more. You can redo the calculation with your own figures in the break-even simulator.
Side-by-side comparison
| Criterion | Direct exporting | Local distributor |
|---|---|---|
| Margin per unit | All the company’s | Shared with the distributor |
| Fixed costs in the market | High | Low |
| Stock and collection risk | The company’s, customer by customer | Concentrated in a single customer |
| Control of price and brand | Full | Limited to what the contract secures |
| Customer information | Direct | Depends on the distributor |
| Cost of leaving the relationship | Agent’s goodwill indemnity, if there is an agent (up to 1 year’s remuneration) | Goodwill indemnity by analogy (Supreme Court ruling n.º 6/2019) |
| Termination notice (open-ended contract) | 1, 2 or 3 months, depending on duration | Art. 28 rule applied by analogy, absent a clause |
Recommendation
It depends mainly on the expected volume and how long you intend to stay in the market.
- New market, uncertain volume or a product that needs local support: the distributor is usually the cheapest way to test, provided the contract has a fixed term, minimum purchase targets and an obligation to share customer data.
- Volume already above your crossover point, or a strategic market: direct selling (own or through an agent) is worth the margin and gives back control of the customer.
- In either case: before signing, write down what it costs to leave — term, notice, governing law and what happens to the customer base. That is where most money is lost, and almost always years later.